Points well Taken Hawk
And lets not forget Thanking You Mr. Hawkster for sticking out your neck on this topic. Certainly you knew you where going to catch heat from some people on this and you threw your hat in anyway. Salute
You know I am a stickler for the facts and logic

I do concur that it is an unfair advantage to use it whilest your opponents are unaware of the fact that you dont know they are using it.
And although I am one of the people who think its not a huge indiscretion I still would be peeved that it was used unknowingly against me. ( the unfair advantage portion). And I still wouldnt mind to see rematches at Thorns inconvenience and them taking a loss for the round if they didnt show or have enough players. It only seems like a fair resolution to the issue.